13 Best Broiler Pans To Buy In 2022, With Buying Guide and Reviews
You can now cook your favorite dishes filled with meat and veggies in a broiler pan.
sakshi john 
In This Article
The days of massive broiler pans, whose use was limited to only special occasions, are long gone. The best broiler pans are compact and super-cute and fit easily in your home oven as well as the sink after you’re done broiling. Using a broiler pan is one of the fastest and most efficient ways to make every meal more flavorful and extract the maximum amount of nutrition from ingredients.
These pans are designed to take the heat at high temperatures and are highly durable, as they are made of stainless or porcelain-coated steel. If you’re looking to step up your cooking and eat healthily, this is a must-have accessory in your kitchen. The options we have listed in this post come with a non-stick coating to make your cooking experience a lot easier. So, check out the reviews and pick the broiler pan that serves your needs.
Top Picks
13 Best Broiler Pans To Buy
1. Best Non-Stick:Nordic Ware 2-Piece Broiler
Are you looking for the best broiler pan for two? Or to broil meals in small quantities? If yes, then the Nordic Ware 2-piece Broiler may be ideal for you. It looks small but is sturdy enough to sustain through high temperatures and will fit easily in any of your kitchen or pan drawers. As for cooking, the pan has a non-stick surface that makes it easy to use and easy to clean too. Also, it comes with a removable and imported rack!
Pros:
- Ideal for the toaster or regular ovens
- Non-stick pan
- Removable and imported rack
- Easy-to-clean
- Recommended for camping, RV stoves, or one-person use
Cons
- The non-stick coating may not last too long.
2. Best Easy-To-Grip:Farberware Non-Stick Steel Roaster
Give that turkey the perfect roaster to cook on! Farberware Non-Stick Steel Roaster is durable and will last through countless happy get-togethers with you. It is made of a heavy-duty and strong steel construction that ensures the meat cooks and browns evenly without leaving hot stops. This non-stick high quality pan has dual-riveted easy-grip handles too that are made of stainless steel and a chrome-plated rack to separate the meat from drippings. Oven-safe up to 450 degrees F, the pan comes with a quality assurance guarantee. Learn about the main features of the product in this video.
Pros:
- Non-stick inside out
- Easy-grip stainless steel handles
- Premium-quality assurance
- Resists warping
- Easy-to-clean and durable
- Hand wash-safe
Cons
- The non-stick coating may not last.
- It is not dishwasher safe.
3. Best Compact:Range Kleen Broil and Bake Pan
This cute and compact broiler pan has enough room to cook for two people! From fitting easily in your sink to being dishwasher-safe, Range Kleen Broil And Bake Pan is a great option for outdoor grills. Made of heavy-duty porcelain, the grate of the grill is what all healthy-eaters will love the most, for it separates the fat drippings from the meat beautifully. Safe to use at a temperature up to 1025 degrees F, this pan also has OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) quality.
Pros
- Easy to use and clean
- Neatly separates grease drippings
- Dishwasher-safe
- It has OEM quality
- High-quality cookware
Cons
- It is not warp-resistant.
4. Best Large-Sized:General Electric Large Broiler Pan
This one has the charm of the classics! Reminding you of your mom or grandma’s broiled meat and fish dishes, General Electric Large Broiler Pan is non-stick and the core material is made of heavy-duty enameled steel. It has a venting slit and serrated design that ensures the meal cooks and browns evenly. Easy to use, this large broiler pan can be used without the rack too. Also, it is dishwasher-safe.
Pros
- Non-stick pan
- Sturdy and large
- Made of heavy-duty enameled steel
- Guarantees uniform cooking and browning
- Dishwasher-safe
Cons
- It is expensive.
5. Best Lightweight:Norpro Broil And Roast Pan Set
Thin, lightweight, and ideal to use for cooking on a date night! Norpro Broil And Roast Pan Set have a unique design that guarantees uniform cooking and crispiness. One of the best broiler pans online especially, for healthy eaters, this 2-piece set has a perforated top that drains all the extra grease and fat released while cooking the meat. Ideal to use in convection toaster ovens, the brand guarantees long-lasting experience because of its sturdy design. Easy to clean and use, go explore all your favorite meat dishes with this broiler pan.
Pros
- Uniform cooking
- Unique design with a perforated top
- Drains all the excess grease
- Easy-to-clean
- Durable
Cons
- The pan is flimsy.
6. Best Rust-Free:P&P CHEF Toaster Oven Tray and Rack Set
This broiler tray screams luxury! Rust-free and durable, both the toaster oven tray and the rack are made of high-quality stainless steel with no Teflon or chemical coatings. Designed with round and smooth edges, it is safe and sturdy with the non-stick rack cooking the meat evenly and without letting it stick to the surface. The 2-set piece also has a mirror finishing to add shine to your broiling experience! Compact enough to fit in any conventional oven or toaster, it is a great product for gifting too.
Pros
- Sturdy and durable
- Rust-free
- Mirror finishing
- Cooks meat evenly
- No chemical coating only stainless steel
- Effortless cleaning and dishwasher-safe
Cons
- It is small.
- There may be signs of rusting if not maintained well.
7. Best Dishwasher-Safe:Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set
Love broiling hamburgers, steak, or salmon? Then you may like using this non-stick broiler pan set by Wilton. Ideal for one serving, it’s perfect for students and bachelors who love to indulge in healthy eating. It is lightweight, convenient to use and clean unlike those large pans. Plus, this broiler pan is made of steel and is non-stick, which means it will drain the excess grease or oil, easily release the meat and cook evenly. Want more? The set comes with a 5-year warranty!
Pros
- Ideal for serving one
- Non-stick
- Easy release and drains excess grease
- Convenient to use
- Dishwasher-safe
Cons
- It may not fit in all ovens.
- It is not durable.
8. Best Quick-Heating:Nordic Ware Non-stick Broiler Pan Set
A broiler pan that caters to all your delicious meat recipes with its sturdy and premium design! Nordic Ware Non-stick Broiler Pan Set has two state-of-the-art broiler pans that guarantee convenient and uniform cooking of everything from meat to salmon. But what really makes it stand out is the quick and even heating experience it offers due to the tri-ply construction that includes a carbon steel core and two layers of aluminum. And since it is also non-stick, it ensures easy release and effortless cleaning!
Pros
- Broil and bake state-of-the-art pans
- Quick and even heating
- Non-stick and easy release
- State of the art pans
- Drains excess oil and fat
- Easy-grip side handles
Cons
- It may not be dishwasher-safe.
- The non-stick coating may wear off.
9. Best No-Splatter:Whirlpool Premium Broil Pan
Ah, the splatter of juices while broiling. Only the thought of cleaning will make you not want to broil anymore. But Whirlpool Premium Broil Pan can help if you are not a fan of splatter or smoke. The set includes a roasting rack that lets the hot air pass and cook evenly, whereas the grid and pan drain and collects the juices neatly. Also, it is easy to clean and use.
Pros
- Versatile broiler pans
- Uniform cooking
- No splatter or smoke experience
- Lightweight, sturdy, and compact
- Easy-to-clean
Cons
- It is not warp-resistant.
- It is pricey.
10. Best Warp-Resistant:Frigidaire Broiler Pan
If you thought broiling meals is an occasional or Thanksgiving thing then you haven’t got yourself a compact broiler pan yet! Like this one, for instance, will satiate your taste buds with countless healthy and delicious meals that you’ll never want to stop broiling again. Lightweight and easy to use, it collects all the extra grease in the vaulted grid thus leaving you with no choice but to eat healthy! Also, it cleans up easily and is warp-resistant.
Pros
- Compact size
- Fits in all ovens
- Lightweight with vaulted grid
- Easy-to-clean
- Warp-resistant
Cons
- It is not sturdy.
- The non-stick coating is flimsy.
11. Best Low-Flared Edges:Tramontina Roasting Pan
Looking for a broiler pan for a special occasion? Tramontina Roasting Pan will not disappoint you for it is designed to cook up a feast in its premium-quality pans. Made of heavy-duty, mirror-polished, and robust stainless steel, even the handles are sturdy and offer extra durability. Designed with low flared-edges for uniform cooking, it also guarantees to look good in your kitchen! A great gifting option for cooking enthusiasts, give Tramontina Roasting Pan a try.
Pros
- Robust and durable
- Low flared-edges to cooks evenly
- Cleans easily
- Ideal for everyday meals and feasts
- Made of premium-restaurant quality.
Cons
- It may warp after regular use.
12. Best For families:GE Broiler Set
This broiler pan set, like its name, may have a minimalistic charm but it serves the purpose to broil the meals deliciously. Sturdy and ideal to serve an entire family, this large broiler pan offers long-lasting usability and without any fancy add-ons guarantees uniform cooking and draining of excess grease. Ideal for family dinners, the broiler pans have a heavy-duty and robust construction for extra durability.
Pros
- Large capacity
- Broils the meat evenly
- higher durability and sturdy
- Easy-to-clean
- Heavy-duty construction
- Ideal for family dinners
Cons
- It may not fit all ovens.
13. Best Scratch-Resistant:Emile Henry Baking Dish
How about a fancy baking dish for a change that is also broiler-safe? Made in France, Emily Henry Baking Dish will add a Gallic touch to your kitchen. A time-honored baking dish made of high-fired Burgundy clay, it has even-heat diffusion and heat retention properties. So much that it can keep the meal warmer for a long time in the dish. Also, it is scratch-resistant and highly durable too. A great broiler pan for those who enjoy high-quality cookware in their kitchen, Emily Henry Baking Dish is one of the best broiler pans to cook in!
Pros
- Durable, sturdy, and scratch-resistant
- Oven, microwave, and broiler-safe
- Keeps the meal warm for a long time
- Made of premium-quality clay
- Even-heat diffusion and heat retention properties
- Dishwasher-safe
Cons
- It is expensive.
There you go, those are some of the best broiler pans for you. But, if you are still confused, read on as we have listed points that will help you pick the right one:
How To Choose The Best Broiler Pan?
Other than broiling healthy meals, the pan must have these features to be the ideal one:
- Should be a heavy-duty, durable and a robust construction
- Pick the one that guarantees uniform cooking and draining of excess grease
- The pan should be warp-resistant.
- It must fit in all toasters and convection ovens.
- It should be dishwasher-safe.
- It should have a non-stick coating for easy release and cleaning.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is A Broiler Pan Dishwasher Safe?
Yes, mostly all broiler pans are dishwasher safe, however, to make sure they are squeaky clean and there is no residue or oil, hand wash it with warm and soapy water.
2. Is Broiling The Same As Grilling?
Yes, to an extent they both are the same. The only difference between broiling and grilling is that broiling is cooking indoors using the oven’s thermostat whereas grilling in cooking outdoors, where you can control heat and also the food gets a charred flavour.
3. Can I Use A Broiler Pan To Bake?
Yes, you can. However, since baking requires uniform heating and cooking, you will have to watch out and turn the food at the right time to avoid uneven or overcooking.
Broiler pans make your meals more flavorful while also keeping the nutrients of all the ingredients intact. Further, they ensure uniform cooking and browning. The best ones are highly durable and made of quality material to last you several festive seasons. They are also lightweight, rust-free, and easy to wash in a machine or with hands. To pick the right broiler pan, make sure it comes with quality non-stick coating and handles and is warp-resistant.
Why Trust MomJunction?
Sakshi John is a keen writer of home essentials. Her articles include well-researched content and ensure reader satisfaction. When it comes to broiler pans, durability, size, and efficiency are the primary factors to consider. After thorough research, she has covered all those parameters in her list of best broiler pans. She also included a buying guide section and answered all your common queries related to broiler pans.
Do you have feedback regarding this article or did we miss out on a particular brand? Write to us in the comments below!
Community Experiences
Join the conversation and become a part of our vibrant community! Share your stories, experiences, and insights to connect with like-minded individuals.